'Suppose - Did It Inspire Imagine'

Paul Simpson investigates Elvis’ 1967 song 'Suppose' and considers whether it inspired John Lennon's classic 'Imagine'.

- An EIN Spotlight by Paul Simpson -

A quiet, chilling ballad, Suppose is worth a listen in its own right.

It is one of a handful of Elvis’s recordings that ¬– like his cover of Dylan’s 'Tomorrow Is A Long Time' – suggests roads he sadly never got to take.

Yet it also intrigues me because of the possibility – and I put it no more strongly than that – that it inspired 'Imagine', the utopian anthem that became John Lennon’s signature song.

 

In this EIN Spotlight respected author Paul Simpson takes a fascinating look at this overlooked song...


Now Updated - See Below for YOUR Feedback and Comments

 

A quiet, chilling ballad, Suppose is worth a listen in its own right.

It is one of a handful of Elvis’s recordings that ¬– like his cover of Dylan’s Tomorrow Is A Long Time – suggests roads he sadly never got to take. Yet it also intrigues me because of the possibility – and I put it no more strongly than that – that it inspired Imagine, the utopian anthem that became John Lennon’s signature song.

The mere suggestion has divided Presley’s legion of fans. On one online forum, some have noted similarities between the songs – one even suggesting "It’s obvious that John Lennon committed plagiarism" ¬– while another countered: "To say this inspired Imagine is ludicrous and there is nothing remotely close between the 2 songs except the titles. Thanks for the laugh."

Suppose has no right to be as good as it is. The song’s co-writers are George Goehring and Sylvia Dee. Goehring is best known for writing Little Donkey while Dee provided the lyrics for Chickery Chick, a song about a chicken with the irritating habit of saying "Chickery chick, cha-la, cha-la, chekala romey/In a bananika bollika wollika" which topped the US charts in 1945. She also co-wrote Moonlight Swim with Ben Weisman for Blue Hawaii. In a bizarre coincidence, Dee died, at the age of 52, eight days before Elvis recorded Suppose in MGM Studios in Culver City, California.

Goehring and Dee’s reflective, desolate ballad clearly intrigued Presley. He can be heard performing it at Graceland on The Home Recordings compilation and, in June 1967, he cut a long and a short version of the song. Elvis's phrasing is impeccable – the pause after "suppose I had no wish" and before "to be alive" is exquisite. Though Elvis sings as if he’s gripped by existential despair, his performance, like the song, is simple and plaintive, letting the haunting lyrics work their magic. When he speculates that the tall green trees may not survive, the thought is mysteriously moving.

This was clearly a song that Elvis cared deeply about and so, inevitably, it was not included in Speedway, the movie for which it was created. It was buried at the film’s soundtrack album, the worst selling in Presley’s career, stalling at No82 in the Billboard charts.

'Suppose' was the final track on the 1968 released album, the last of five 'Bonus Songs'

 

But did this ballad inspire Imagine? The case that it did can be simply summarised. Suppose and Imagine are synonyms. In both songs, the singer lists a number of things that might not exist. In both numbers, the singer is alone at the piano, contemplating another world. Both songs feature many lines that begin with a single repeated word – suppose or imagine. And in the verse Elvis repeats, he sings, "It’s impossible to imagine a world without a star, but imagining no you …" And the timeline – Suppose was cut in June 1967, Imagine in July 1971 – means that the inspirational influence cannot be ruled out.

 

This could just all add up to a heap of coincidences. Certainly the official version of the creation of Imagine does not mention the soundtrack to Speedway, Elvis or Suppose. Lennon said: "The song was originally inspired by Yoko’s book Grapefruit. In it are a lot of pieces, imagine this, imagine that. Yoko actually helped me a lot with the lyrics, but I wasn’t man enough to give her credit for it."

Published in 1963, Grapefruit contained a three-line poem called Cloud Piece, which starts with the line "Imagine the clouds dripping", which was reproduced on the back of the Imagine album. And the political content of the song – what Lennon called it’s "sugar coated … anti-religious, anti-nationalistic, anti-conventional, anti-capitalistic" message – has no real parallel in Elvis’s oeuvre, although some of the same humanitarian concern runs through his impassioned rendition of If I Can Dream.

The popular cliché is that Lennon stopped listening to Elvis in 1958 when the King went into the army. Yet for all of the former Beatle’s well-publicised swipes at his idol, that isn’t quite true. Lennon is said to have been in the audience when the King sold out Madison Square Garden in 1972. His old band-mate George Harrison even went backstage to meet Presley.

Eight years later, during production of (Just Like) Starting Over, Lennon jokingly referred to the song as the "Elvis/Orbison track". On the stripped down version released in 2010, he says: "This one’s for Gene, and Eddie and Elvis … and Buddy." His homage to the King is particularly obvious on the line "It’s been too long since we took the time …"

That sign of respect was no whim. Listening to the music he had adored as a boy revived Lennon’s interest in music. Nine years before, as Richard Williams has recalled (Guardian article here) he was staying at New York’s St Regis Hotel and sifting through a load of old Elvis singles he had asked someone to buy for him. Sifting through them, Lennon said to Williams: "I’m going to have a jukebox with just Elvis records on it, isn’t it great?" (My Baby Left Me, Hound Dog and Love Me Tender made the cut, Bossa Nova Baby and Are You Lonesome Tonight? didn’t). He also admitted to Williams how he pinched bits from his favourite rock and roll numbers to use in his songs.

This was the same year he recorded Imagine, which was produced by Phil Spector, an even more ardent admirer of Elvis than the Beatles. Interviewed by Rolling Stone in 1969, Spector gushed: "Gosh, Elvis is so great. You have no idea how great he is, you really you don’t. He is sensational. He can do anything with his voice."

It is possible to envisage Spector buying the Speedway album – even though he would have detested it. It is possible to imagine Lennon making the same purchase –if only out of sardonic curiosity to see how low his hero had fallen. Yet there is no proof – and that is where the case for Suppose as a possible inspiration for Imagine ultimately rests. Only if the Lennon family decide to auction/disclose his entire record collection will we ever definitively know.

And ultimately it doesn’t really matter. Suppose is still a beautiful ballad, sung with commitment and intelligence by the greatest singer of the 20th century.

Spotlight written by Paul Simpson (images by Piers Beagley)
-Copyright EIN July 2015

EIN Website content © Copyright the Elvis Information Network.

Click HERE to comment on this article
(Note - If you don't use outlook express simply email piers@elvisinfonet.com )

 

DON'T MISS these recent, previous fascinating EIN Spotlights by Paul Simpson

'Trains, Jet Planes and Morning Rain' EIN Spotlight:

'Big Boss Man: What Kind of Technical Advice Did Parker Provide for Elvis’s Movies?':

"If You're Going To Start A Rumble" -The Importance of Fights In Elvis Movies:

 

 

 


EIN Reader's Feedback

From Cesar Emilio R
It's a good song but I highly doubt Lennon would seek out Speedway on vinyl but stranger things have happened.
What I do know is this song deserved a better fate than being buried on this LP.

EIN Piers
I strongly suspect that Lennon's producer Phil Spector will have obtained every Elvis album for free, especially due to his work with the "Wrecking Crew" musicians in LA some of whom worked on the Speedway session. While the soundtrack was awful one can "imagine" Phil Spector playing the "Bonus Songs" to hear what Elvis might have been recording away from the mundane movie songs. So I believe that it is likely that Spector would have listened to 'Suppose' at some point - NOT that this means it in anyway would have influenced Lennon's Imagine. But it is another coincidence and possible link.


From Drew B
Good shout....I never thought of that until now.
Lennon was a huge fan of Elvis remember so I would guess he would look out for the bonus songs on an album.. the Piano Ballads especially

From Marvin B

Listen to Little Sister and then listen to Get Back. They sound alike

From Sharon E
Beautiful song by ELVIS!!!
I for One, can most definitely "imagine",,, this being the inspiration for Lennon.

From Ali C
I always said this song was on a par with Imagine !
It's a beautiful song sung by the most beautiful voice in the world and shoulld have been realeased as a single !

From Scott H
I imagine it's possible I suppose. But would John Lennon have listened to the Speedway soundtrack? and his song lyrics are cherry picked from the musings in Yoko's book. So then, did Yoko base her whole philosophy on the Speedway soundtrack? is the very title amphetimine related? is 'let yourself go' a recipe to find real love?

From Cesar Emilio R
It's a good song but I highly doubt Lennon would seek out Speedway on vinyl but stranger things have happened.

What I do know is this song deserved a better fate than being buried on this LP.

Pat O'D
In some ways Lennon's life mirrored Elvis', the specs, drugs, becoming a recluse, syrupy songs in their final years, hair etc .

About this song on Imagine (the most stupid song that Lennon wrote as if everything that he wrote came true and everything went away! All you needed is for one bloke to mess with another man's missus and you would be back to the beginning).
Best to have what we got and work on that.
I think Yoko would be a unreliable source, you could not trust her if she said no.
Suppose is a great song tho a gem .

From Alex C
The lyrics of John Lennon's anthem were by John Lennon admission written by Yoko Ono which hated Elvis Presley by her own admission.
John always said that he loved Elvis ( even if,  being widely into drugs, he often referred erratically about his love of Elvis & about meeting him, which was a dream of his) until he met Yoko Ono ( she liked old time music & jazz crooners but not r'n'r generation of singers like Elvis ) he then tended to stay away from his roots but, he spontaneously shouted (during the performance of Elvis's classic number Hound Dog) "Elvis I love you" in his 1972 New York Concerts .
So sorry, you can't even "Suppose" maybe inspired John Lennon's  classic, you can just "Imagine" it.
Thank you for your time & your mind

Click HERE to send us YOUR FEEDBACK on this article
(Note - If you don't use outlook express simply email piers@elvisinfonet.com )

 

Interview with 'Elvis Films FAQ' author Paul Simpson: "Elvis Films FAQ"  was reviewed by EIN as one of the best Elvis books published in 2013... "Paul Simpson examines every angle of Elvis’ film career and writes about it in a very engaging and enjoyable style. The real triumph of this book is that it will make you want to watch all of Elvis’ films one more time! Highly recommended."

While Elvis' Hollywood years are full of mystery, and Elvis Films FAQ covers them all! Elvis Films FAQ explains everything you want to know about the whys and wherefores of the singer-actor's bizarre celluloid odyssey; or, as Elvis said, "I saw the movie and I was the hero of the movie."
 
"Elvis Films FAQ" was without doubt one of the best Elvis books published in 2013 and EIN wanted to know more from its author Paul Simpson.
 
(Interviews, Source;ElvisInfoNet)

'Elvis Films FAQ' Book Review: Elvis' Hollywood years are full of mystery, and supposedly 'Elvis Films FAQ' covers them all! Elvis Films FAQ by author Paul Simpson explores his best and worst moments as an actor, analyses the bizarre autobiographical detail that runs through so many of his films, and reflects on what it must be like to be idolized by millions around the world yet have to make a living singing about dogs, chambers of commerce, and fatally naive shrimps.
After all if Elvis Presley had not wanted to be a movie star, he would never have single-handedly revolutionized popular culture.
Yet this aspect of his phenomenal career has been much maligned and misunderstood – partly because the King himself once referred to his 33 movies as a rut he had got stuck in just off Hollywood Boulevard.

It is a mightly entertaining book - but go here as EIN's Piers Beagley investigates to see whether this new book by author Paul Simpson really answers all the questions you need to know ....

(Book Reviews, Source;ElvisInfoNet)

.


EIN Website content © Copyright the Elvis Information Network.
Elvis Presley, Elvis and Graceland are trademarks of Elvis Presley Enterprises.
The Elvis Information Network has been running since 1986 and is an EPE officially recognised Elvis fan club.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Did You Miss these Popular Interviews?
Linda and Sam Thompson in Australia:
John Wilkinson Tribute & 1972 Interview:
(Interview) Anne E. Nixon answers your questions
Ginger Alden Interview:
Elaine Beckett -Easy Come Easy Go costar- Interview:
Shirley Dieu, author of Memphis Mafia Princess, talks to EIN:
Interview With Elvis author - : Gillian G. Gaar
Interview with Dick Grob, Elvis' Head Of Security:
Hollywood veteran Michael Hoey talks to EIN:
Interview with 'Elvis Films FAQ' author Paul Simpson:
"My Fast Life" Rare Elvis Presley 1964 Interview:
RIP - Bernard Lansky talks to EIN:
Allyson Adams 'The Rebel and The King' Interview: 
Joseph A. Tunzi
David Stanley (2012)
Author Chris Kennedy Interview about D.J. Tommy Edwards:
Vernon Presley Interview:
Jerry Leiber Interview for EIN
Elvis Paradise Hawaiian Interview - with Peter Noone
Sam Thompson, Elvis' bodyguard, 2011 Interview
James Burton Interview - Rick Nelson & Elvis:
Elvis Drummer Jerome "Stump" Monroe EIN Interview:
Donnie Sumner Remembers his friend Sherrill Nielsen: 
Lamar Fike EIN Exclusive Interview
Jamie Aaron Kelley - EIN Interview:
Ernst Jorgensen interview about 'The Complete Masters' and more:
D.J Fontana Interview - Elvis Week 2010 special: 
Red West Interview:- 2010 Elvis week special
Linda Thompson - Interview Special:
Elvis in 1969 - Ann Moses & Ray Connolly Interviews:
Ernst Jorgensen interview about 'On Stage' and Elvis' Legacy in 2010:
Paul Lichter
Dr. Nick talks to EIN
Alanna Nash
Ernst Jorgensen (2009)
Joseph Pirzada
Jeanne LeMay Dumas
Larry Geller
Mac Davis
Roger Semon
Ernst Jorgensen
Wayne Jackson (Memphis Horns)
Ernst Jorgensen (Record Collector)
 
Did You Miss these Popular EIN articles
EIN Spotlight on Aloha's director Marty Pasetta
'Elvis - The UK's 'Most Successful Chart Act':
FTD "What now, What next, What If? PART TWO ":
Elvis and the Coco Palms Resort:
FTD "What now, What next, What If?":
Is 'From Elvis In Memphis' the only Elvis album you need to own?:
EIN's 'Elvis Star Track' Of The Week
'Trains, Jet Planes and Morning Rain' EIN Spotlight:
Wertheimer's Reaction To Finding The 'Mystery Kisser':
UPDATED - 'Elvis Madison 1977 - The Gas Station Incident' with Kathy Westmoreland:
"If You're Going To Start A Rumble" -The Importance of Fights In Elvis Movies:
ELVIS WEEK 2014 - EIN exclusive Sanja Meegin reports:
'Big Boss Man: What Kind of Technical Advice Did Parker Provide for Elvis’s Movies?':
UPDATED - 'American Studios 1969 - A Turning Point In History':
'The Nation's Favourite Elvis Song' Spotlight
Linda and Sam Thompson in Australia:
Elvis Passwords - We’ve Hacked them all! 
Fourteen Key Elvis Singles:
Elvis And The Vocal Group Tradition:
Happy Birthday EIN EIN turns 100 – a retrospective!:
Aloha From Hawaii - The Concert 2013- EIN Exclusive
Elvis at Madison Square Garden 40 Years Ago
'The Wedding' Elvis & Priscilla EIN special Spotlight:
'Elvis In Ottawa' Spotlight & Elvis Interview:
'Elvis: Live at the International' Book Review:
Book Review: Elvis in Vegas
'Promised Land' FTD CD Review:
"Kissed By Elvis" Janet Fulton Interview:
'1956, Elvis Presley’s Pivotal Year':
"ReBooked At The International'- in-depth Review:
EIN Spotlight on Alfred Wertheimer:
'Elvis Memphis to Madison 1977' The Gas Station Incident:
'Elvis In Concert' 1977 TV special; Should it be released officially?
Ernst Jorgensen interview about 'The Complete Masters' and more:
Dark Side of the Colonel
 
Did you miss these Reviews
'Elvis Files Magazine ISSUE 11' Review:
(Book Review) 'Lee Gordon Presents Elvis Presley - The Biggest Shows of 1957' Volume 2:
'Nashville Chrome' - (Maxine Brown & Elvis) Book Review:
'Rock Around The Bloch' FTD Book Review
'Elvis' Christmas Album' FTD Review:
'Flaming Star' FTD Review
Is 'From Elvis In Memphis' the only Elvis album you need to own?
'Ultimate Elvis' Book Review
(Book Review): Elvis Presley: A Southern Life
(Book Review) The world knows Elvis Presley....but they don't know me:
The Elvis Films (Book Review)
'Elvis In Florida April 1975' FTD In-Depth Review:
'Autopsy: The Last Hours Of Elvis' - Review:
(Book Review): CHANNELING ELVIS How Television Saved the King of Rock 'n' Roll:
(Book Review) Elvis and Ginger:
'Elvis Files Magazine ISSUE 8' Review:
(Book Review) Memphis Mafia Princess:
'Final Countdown To Midnight' NYE 1976 - in-depth Review:
'ELVIS' FTD Classic Album Review:
(Book Review) 100 Things Elvis Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die:
'Elvis-The King Of The Jungle' In-Depth Book Review:
(Book Review): Elvis' Favorite Director:Norman Taurog:
'ELVIS AT 21' Exhibition Review:
'Elvis Music FAQ' - Book Review:
'Elvis Films FAQ' Book Review:
'The On Stage Season' FTD In-Depth Review:
'The Elvis Files Vol. 6 1971-1973'  Book Review:
'Love Me Tender' Blu-Ray Edition Review:
'Houston We Have A Problem' - CD review:
'SOLD OUT' FTD CD Review:
‘Elvis At Stax’ [Deluxe] Reviews:
'The Elvis Files Vol. 6 1971-1973'  Book Review:
'Love Me Tender' Blu-Ray Edition Review:
'Houston We Have A Problem' - CD review:
'Hot August Night' FTD CD Review:
'Elvis - Aloha Via Satellite: A 40th Anniv Release' Book Review:
'Aloha From Hawaii' 40th Anniv LEGACY CD Review:
Aloha From Hawaii - The Concert 2013- EIN Exclusive Review:
‘Elvis On Tour’ E-book Review - with Great jumpsuit photos-
'From Elvis Presley Boulevard' FTD In-Depth Review:
'Prince From Another Planet’ In-Depth Review:
'Elvis: Walk A Mile In My Shoes' - EIN Review:
‘Greatest Live Hits of the 50s’ MRS CD Review: 
Once Upon A Time: Elvis and Anita (Memories of My Mother) - Book Review:
'A Boy From Tupelo' special In-depth Review:
Bootleg Elvis (Book Review)
 
Audio-Visual
Best of Elvis on YouTube
Graceland cam
EPE's Multimedia Elvis Gallery
Sirius Elvis Satellite Radio
Elvis Radio (ETA's)
Elvis Express Radio
Ultimate Elvis Radio
Elvis Only Radio
"Images in Concert" PhotoDatabase
Radio Interview: Vernon & Gladys Presley
Sanja's Elvis Week 2007 Photo Gallery
'EIN's Best of Elvis on YouTube'
The Music of Elvis Presley - Australian Radio Show
Reference
All about Elvis
All about Elvis Tribute Artists
All about Graceland
All about Lisa Marie Presley
Ancestors of Elvis
Art Archives
Book Releases 2009
Contact List
Elvis and Racism
Elvis as Religion
Elvis CDs in 2007
Elvis DVDs in 2006
Elvis Film Guide
'2007 New Releases'
Elvis Presley In Concert "downunder" 2006
Elvis Online Virtual Library
Elvis Research Forum
Elvis Rules on Television
Graceland - The National Historic Landmark
How & where do I sell my Elvis collection?
Is Elvis the best selling artist?
Links to Elvis' family & friends
Links to other Elvis sites
Marty's Musings
Online Elvis Symposium
Parkes Elvis Festival 2009 (Australia)
Presley Law legal archives (Preslaw)
Presleys In The Press
Sale of EPE (Archives)
6th Annual Elvis Website Survey
Spotlight on The King
"Wikipedia" Elvis biography