"Three
Way Dance": Battle of the Photo Journals!
Nigel
Patterson, July 1, 2003
|
EIN
compares three new Elvis photo-books letting them do battle
in an all-out 3 way dance:
Elvis
PA Klass Hold
Elvis
Behind The Image
The
Rock 'n' Roll Years My Wish Came True, Vol. 1
Who
will go down for the count?
|
Elvis
PA Kloss Hold, Yngvar Holm (Flaming Star, Oslo, 2002, Hardcover,
136pp, ISBN: 8299515327)
With
photographs principally from the archives of Pal Granlund, Yngvar
Holm and Ed Bonja this is a quality release with a strong page design
and clear illustrations. The downside is that the substantive text
is all in Norwegian (with the exception of a chronology of Elvis's
live concerts). The photos are a mix of the rare and prosaic, making
this release seem similar to many others.
The
book is a high quality production, nicely split into sections with
color and b/w visuals neatly highlighting each one. The well-designed
sections include Colonel Tom Parker, the Hollywood years, the Madison
Square Garden concerts and Elvis, Priscilla and Lisa. Elvis Kloss
PA Hold is a good addition to your ‘coffee table’ library.
Elvis
Behind The Image, Bud Glass (Praytome Publishing, 2003, Hardcover,
126pp, ISBN: none)
This
is a book of mainly candid shots of Elvis at rest and play,
away from the stage and screen. Given the informal nature
of the photos they generally aren't as clear as the stills
in the other two photo-journals.
The
photos are from the archives of Russ Howe and Sandy Miller.
Ms Miller also provides text and journal notes to complement
the visuals. The narrative is relatively brief and does not
compare with the detailed text in the other two releases.
|
|
The
book includes an interesting photo section ‘The California Homes
of Elvis Presley’ and there are great photos taken on the sets of
Stay Away, Joe and Charro and a series of visuals from the historic
Houston Livestock shows. While the photos in Behind The Image have
apparently ‘never been seen before’ they are very similar to others
that have been previously published from the Howe and Miller archives.
The
Rock 'N' Roll Years My Wish Came True Volume 1, Ger Rijff, JeanPaul
Commandeur & Trevor Cajiao (Elvis Unlimited, Denmark, 2003, Hardcover,
unpaginated, ISBN; none)
|
This
is the best designed of the three releases. It features interestingly
varied text and neatly presented photos. Ger Rijff is a name
synonymous with the very best in photo-journals and My Wish
Came True continues the very high standards set by Rijff in
earlier publications such as Florida Close-Up, Memphis Lonesome
and Shock, Rattle & Roll.
A
lot of thought went into the page design and it has paid off.
Apart from rare photos of The Hillbilly Cat during his halcyon
days the release is designed to be dramatic, with frenetic
up-close shots of Elvis and hysterical fans.
|
In
addition, the inclusion of press ads, record charts and promotional
material from the time adds significant historical importance to
the book.
The
only negative with My Wish Came True is its soft cover format that
means careful storage and handling is necessary to preserve a release
you will revisit many times. Given the age of the visuals the photo
quality is surprisingly good and the 'in your face' presentation
is striking.
Most
of the Elvis photos are b/w while many of the historical materials
are in color. Trevor Cajiao contributes a thoughtful essay, 'Early
Memories of the Hillbilly Cat '54-'56'. It quickly transports readers
into the musical fabric of the magical 50s era. My Wish Came True
comes with a bonus interview/dialogue CD.
Verdict:
All three books are printed on high quality paper stock and all
three offer something different. My Wish Came True presents
a valuable historical photo-journal of The King at the peak of Elvis-mania.
Elvis Behind The Image offers rare candids of Elvis "off-camera"
and Elvis PA Kloss Hold provides detailed text (in Norwegian)
and a great array of visuals from throughout Elvis's life and career.
At the end of the day it probably comes down to what one is interested
in.
EIN
has rated the three books on the following basis:
|
Book
Page Design |
Clarity
of Visuals |
Quality
of Text |
Historical
Significance of Content |
Book
Durability |
Elvis
PA Klass Hold |
7.5
|
9
|
8*
|
6
|
9
|
Elvis
Behind The Image |
7
|
6.5
|
4
|
7
|
9
|
The
Rock 'n' Roll Years |
10
|
8
|
8
|
9
|
5
|
*
As I can’t read Norwegian, I asked a friend fluent in the language
to read several pages at random so I could gauge the quality of
the text
Copyright
EIN, 2004
Click
to comment on this review
|